Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you hit links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Never deal with burnt cookies again.
Photo:Real Simple
You shouldn’t buy just any old sheet pan, though.
You want one that’s durable with even heating for uniform cooking.
(We madechocolate chip cookiesand potato wedges.)
PHOTO: Amazon
After seeing how well they performed in all of our tests, we’re on the exact same page.
Despite the oven being cranked up to 475F, the pan didn’t warp at all.
Since it’s so large, it may be difficult to maneuver in the oven and sink.
Real Simple
While some visible fingerprints were left behind, the cleanup process was ultimately hassle-free.
Overall, we think this large sheet is perfect for serving parties and prepping meals for the week.
Material:Aluminum |Dimensions:22 by 16 in.
PHOTO: Amazon
Its an expensive choice for people who dont bake often.
After seeing how perfect the final product was, we would trust this pan with any recipe.
It can also handle very high heat (up to 550F), which isnt common with nonstick cookware.
Real Simple
Because of this, we found this pan to be extremely durable and believe that its built to last.
or 15 by 10 in.
Its thickness makes it less suitable for roasting.
PHOTO: Amazon
The cleaning process was similarly hassle-free, with no scrubbing required.
This baking sheet can also handle heat up to 450F.
It survived being in the broiler and didnt warp, either.
PHOTO: Amazon
Sheet pan dinner enthusiastswill love this roaster-friendly baking sheet.
Its large size also makes it perfect for preparing big batches of food.
Plus, unlike many other baking sheets, you could put this one in the dishwasher.
Real Simple
What stands out about the Holy Sheet is its beautiful collection of vibrant color options.
If you’re seeking a less-expensive option, we recommend theWinco ALXP Aluminum Baking Sheet.
Its lightweight design and spacious size make it ideal for hosting and meal prepping.
PHOTO: Great Jones
Our first test involved making chocolate chip cookies on the baking sheets.
Our second test involved roasting potato wedges.
We also noted if the pan warped and how easy it was to clean after it cooled down completely.
Real Simple
We took all this information to come up with the best baking sheets.
Aluminum is such a great conductor of heat that you will also find baking sheets made of aluminum only.
Chonody says one drawback of aluminum is that it reacts to acidic foods like tomatoes or citrus.
Nonstick
Nonstick baking sheets are great for people who wantsupremely easy cleanup.
During testing, we found this to be true.
The finish will start degrading and lead to peeling and flaking, Chonody says.
Be sure to read your instruction manual to confirm the temperatures your nonstick baking sheet can handle.
Because darker pans absorb heat, they also hold on to heat longer.
This heat can result in crispier roasted veggies or baked goods with browned bottoms.
For this reason, McKenney uses lighter-colored pans when baking.
