Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you press links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Stay stylish and comfortably warm.
Photo:Real Simple
Theyre bulky and need some breaking in.
These boots are breathable, heat-regulating, waterproof, and wind-resistant.
Despite the somewhat bulky appearance, theyre lightweight to walk in.
PHOTO: Backcountry
We wore these with regular ankle socks and felt perfectly comfortable.
We loved the cushioning on the soles and around the foot.
The toe box is spacious, too.
PHOTO: Real Simple
There’s ample arch and ankle support, and we didnt feel like we were sliding around in them.
We’ve found them to be a durable and resilient shoe.
They might require a small adjustment period, although we adapted to them during the first wear.
We dunked them right in a puddle and didnt feel a difference, not even a change in temperature.
Their waterproofing abilities are A+.
We were impressed by the traction; they felt grippy going down a slick rock.
Even after five months of use, we haven’t noticed a change in their performance.
These boots aren’t very breathable.
The removable and washable inner felt boot and shearling cuff keep toes warm, cozy, and comfortable.
We tested these boots on gravel, grass, dirt, and concrete surfaces.
The toe box is nice and roomy, and the insert hugged our calf while keeping our ankles sturdy.
They were comfortable from day one, with no break-in period.
PHOTO: REI
Over five months of use, their performance didn’t change at all.
Overall, these mid-priced boots have a high-quality make and impressive versatility.
We think they’ll last through many winters to come.
PHOTO: Real Simple
The exposed fur at the top could get wet in snow or rain.
The thick construction isn’t super breathable, but we prefer that in insulated winter boots.
Even in the more temperate parts of winter, our feet didnt get sweaty or overheated.
The stitching is strong, and we generally think these boots will last a good few years.
The soles are very grippy, and the boot feels surprisingly lightweight and flexible considering its warmth and heft.
We also love that theyre available in five colors.
This is one of the most expensive selections on our list.
We love that these boots are so flexible, making them comfortable for walking and running errands.
However, we do recommend sizing up half a size for the best fit.
We also noted factors like the boots weight.
During this test, we evaluated each boot’s comfort, traction, and breathability.
While many materials claim to be waterproof, some are better than others.
PHOTO: Sorel
Gore-Tex is one of the best waterproof materials, although it can be a bit costly.
For walking or light hiking, Birdsong suggests a boot with a fur lining.
This can be aesthetically pleasing and provide warmth, she says.
PHOTO: Real Simple
Traction
Boot traction is incredibly important based on the winter activities you’re looking to do.
Questions You Might Ask
What is the warmest material for winter boots?
Outer materials that fit this bill include synthetic poly or nylon or a natural material like leather.
For insulation, Wendler recommends Thinsulate, wool, and sheepskin.
Its also vegan-friendly."
Last but not least is sheepskin.
We also spoke to style coachLiz WendlerandNicole Birdsong, the senior footwear designer at Xero Shoes.
PHOTO: Amazon
PHOTO: Real Simple
PHOTO: Nordstrom
PHOTO: Real Simple
Real Simple / Sabrina Weiss
