Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.

If you punch links we provide, we may receive compensation.

These picks go the distanceliterally.

Real Simple Tests Tape Measures: The Irwin Strait-Line, Stanley Fatmax, and MasterForce

Photo:Real Simple

Theyre especially essential for new homes or apartments with a blank canvas in need of decorating.

To come up with this list, we tested 34 tape measures (yes, 34!)

Take a look at our full review below.

Irwin Strait-Line Tape Measure

PHOTO: Lowe’s

It’s a bit bulky.

Overall, this tape measure performed well on all tests.

Those seeking a compact option would be better off with another pick from our list.

Hand measures piece of metal on table with a Irwin Strait-Line Tape Measure

PHOTO: Real Simple

Blade Length:16, 25, 30, 35 ft. |Blade Width:1 in.

|Blade Material:Steel |Weight:2 lbs.

Best Basic

Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure

It’s unfussy and gets the job done.

Person doing measurement through Irwin Strait-Line Tape Measure

It doesn’t have a very long standout.

The 1/8-inch markings are clear and not too cluttered, which helps ensure accuracy while reading the measurements.

We recommend it for anyone looking for a durable yet affordable tape measure.

Person wearing Irwin Strait-Line Measure tape with hip belt

Blade Length:12, 16, 25, 30 ft. |Blade Width:1 in.

|Blade Material:Steel |Weight:1 lb.

Easiest-to-Read

DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure

It has extra-large numbers and is very durable.

Irwin Strait-Line Tape Measures displayed with pencils on a white surface

The recoil is particularly powerful.

For thoseworking on a home renovation, the DeWalt ToughSeries Tape Measure is a good one to have around.

The DeWalt tape measure proved to be quite durable and only sustained minor scuffs in the process.

Hand measures piece of metal on table with a Irwin Strait-Line Tape Measure

Still, we think this difference is so small that it wouldnt be a problem in most cases.

Just be cautious when reeling it in, as we found the recoil to be pretty powerful.

Blade Length:16 ft. |Blade Width:1 in.

Person doing measurement through Irwin Strait-Line Tape Measure

|Blade Material:Steel |Weight: 2 lbs.

Best Auto-Locking

Milwaukee Compact Auto-Lock Tape Measure

The thumb lock is easy to use.

We noticed smudging on the blade.

Person wearing Irwin Strait-Line Measure tape with hip belt

Thats why we think the Milwaukee Compact Auto-Lock Tape Measure is worth considering.

It has an easy-to-reach, spring-loaded thumb button for a lock, rather than a switch.

We also like that the button lock made retracting the blade easier to control.

Irwin Strait-Line Tape Measures displayed with pencils on a white surface

In terms of accuracy, all measurements were precise.

Blade Length:16, 25 ft. |Blade Width:1 in.

|Blade Material:Steel |Weight:1 lb.

Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure

PHOTO: The Home Depot

Best Professional

Stanley FatMax Tape Measure

It’s ideal for metal stud framing work.

The standout isn’t quite what’s listed.

For a professional-quality option, we recommend the Stanley FatMax Tape Measure.

Person extending the Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure over a table with a metal ruler

PHOTO: Real Simple

The blade comes with a special coating that protects it from damage.

But we did encounter some difficulties when we tried to pause recoiling and then start again.

Blade Length:16, 25 ft. |Blade Width:1 in.

Hands measuring the width of the Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure with a metal ruler

|Blade Material:Steel |Weight:2 lbs.

If you prefer something more economical, we recommend theMilwaukee Compact Tape Measure.

Whenever possible, we tested the 16- and 25-foot versions of each tape measure.

Person extending the Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure

We noted where it bent each time and compared this to any manufacturer’s claims.

Here, we considered whether the recoil felt smooth and clean or hard to control.

Finally, we put the tape measures through a series of drop tests.

Person measuring with the Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure

The blade is the part of the tape measure that has the measurements on it, says Jantz.

It is the tape in a tape measure.

Different brands offer blades of various lengths, with 25 feet being the most common.

Person reading the measurements on Milwaukee Compact Auto-Lock Tape Measure

However, there are other sizes available such as 16 feet, 35 feet, and even 100 feet.

Blade Width

Blade width is also important when it comes to getting accurate measurements.

That being said, Greenwell believes that a fiberglass tape measure is actually the most versatile.

Person measuring steel using Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure

Most other countries, however, use the metric system, which measures distance in meters and centimeters.

However, Jantz says auto-locking and a large standout are usually the most valuable features for most people.

If you’re looking for auto-locking, we particularly like theMilwaukee Compact Auto-Lock Tape Measure.

Milwaukee Compact Tape Measures displayed on white desk

Person extending the Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure over a table with a metal ruler

Hands measuring the width of the Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure with a metal ruler

Person extending the Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure

Person measuring with the Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure

Person reading the measurements on Milwaukee Compact Auto-Lock Tape Measure

Person measuring steel using Milwaukee Compact Tape Measure

Milwaukee Compact Tape Measures displayed on white desk

DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure

PHOTO: Home Depot

DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure is being measured with another tape measure

PHOTO: Real Simple

Person measures wall using DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure

Person extends the DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure above a wooden table

Hand measures steel piece through DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure

Hand taking DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure from hip belt

DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure lie on floor

DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure is being measured with another tape measure

Person measures wall using DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure

Person extends the DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure above a wooden table

Hand measures steel piece through DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure

Hand taking DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure from hip belt

DeWalt Tough Series Tape Measure lie on floor

Milwaukee Compact Auto-Lock Tape Measure

PHOTO: The Home Depot

Milwaukee Compact Auto-Lock Tape Measure placed on a white desk

Milwaukee Compact Auto-Lock Tape Measure placed on a white desk

Stanley FatMax Tape Measure

PHOTO: Courtesy by Acme Tools

Person measuring wall using Stanley FatMax Tape Measure

PHOTO: Real Simple

Stanley FatMax Tape Measure displayed on desk

Person measuring wall using Stanley FatMax Tape Measure

Stanley FatMax Tape Measure displayed on desk

DeWalt Tape Measure

Real Simple

Stanley Fatmax 25ft Tape Measure

Real Simple

Lufkin Shockforce Dual Sided 16ft Measuring Tape

Real Simple