Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.

If you press links we provide, we may receive compensation.

We tested 29 pairs of flats to bring you four that deserve a spot in your closet.

A person wears the Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane outside

Photo:Real Simple

It also doesnt mean that you have to sacrifice style in your search for a comfortable flat.

We get that all-day comfort is important.

Take a look at our list of winners belowit’s time to find your new favorite flat.

Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane

PHOTO: Rothy’s

The straps dont adjust, so you cant make them tighter or looser.

Because of their durable sole, these flats were far from flimsy and didnt create any discomfort or pain.

They also didnt bend easily, and after regular use, there were no signs of wear and tear.

Feet wearing a pair of Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane on concrete

PHOTO: Real Simple

Overall, we felt completely supported and secure in this flat.

Support may vary depending on the color you get.

At $40, these landed the spot for our best budget pick.

Feet wearing a pair of Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane on concrete

The price doesnt mean the shoes skimped on quality, though.

We even felt that these could replace our more expensive flats on occasion.

The simple, classic design makes these a greateveryday pick for jeans, skirts, and even dress pants.

Hand holding a pair of Rothy’s The Square Mary Janes

They also could have more grip at the bottom.

Because of this, we felt that they might not be the best option for walking on slick surfaces.

The fabric might not hold up long term as well as others.

Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane flats displayed on a wood floor

We also never experienced any pinching, rubbing, or blisteringthere was no break-in period for this shoe.

The knit upper didnt feel too thin, and the overall quality was evident throughout the shoe.

At $245, theyre the most expensive on our list.

Feet wearing a pair of Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane on concrete

The leather also softened with wear, making them even more snug and comfortable.

With 10 equally classic colors to choose from, its perfect for adding to your capsule wardrobe.

A flat with inadequate arch support can lead to foot fatigue, plantar fasciitis, and other discomforts.

Feet wearing a pair of Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane on concrete

For a pick with optimal arch support, we recommend theVionic Caroll Ballet Flatwith its removable microfiber-wrapped EVA footbed.

Material

Both Dr. Abdoo and Rosson recommend leather or suede for a comfortable yet stylish flat.

Next is the makeup of the sole.

Hand holding a pair of Rothy’s The Square Mary Janes

Rubber and cork materials are preferred sole materials.

Finally, we got expert input fromDr.

Shital Sharma, DPM, a board-certified podiatrist with Pinewood Family Care Co.,Dr.

Rothy’s The Square Mary Jane flats displayed on a wood floor

David Abdoo, DPM, a podiatrist at Salinas Valley Foot & Ankle, and stylistsVanessa ValienteandJennifer Rosson.

Amazon Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flat

PHOTO: Amazon

Feet wearing Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flats on carpet

PHOTO: Real Simple

Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flats displayed on a wood floor

Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flats displayed on carpet

Feet wearing Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flats on carpet

Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flats displayed on a wood floor

Frank Mully Round Toe Ballet Flats displayed on carpet

Vivaia Pointed-Toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats

PHOTO: Vivaia

Feet wearing Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats on a wood floor

PHOTO: Real Simple

Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats displayed on a wood floor

Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats displayed on a white surface

Feet wearing Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats on a wet sidewalk

Feet wearing Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats on a wood floor

Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats displayed on a wood floor

Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats displayed on a white surface

Feet wearing Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats on a wet sidewalk

Margaux The Demi Flat

PHOTO: Margaux

Margaux The Demi Flats displayed on their shoebox on carpet

PHOTO: Real Simple

Margaux The Demi Flats displayed on a coffee table

Margaux The Demi Flats displayed on their shoebox on carpet

Margaux The Demi Flats displayed on a coffee table

Hand holding a pair of Rothy’s The Square Mary Janes

Real Simple

A person wearing Vivaia Aria 5° Pointed-toe Water Repellent Ballet Flats on a wet sidewalk

Real Simple