Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you press links we provide, we may receive compensation.
Our top picks include sneakers, flats, heels, and more.
Photo:Real Simple
Sneakers
There are tons of comfort-focused sneakers out there.
Scholls Time Off Sneakerand theSorel Ona Ave Low Waterproof Sneaker.
We absolutely love theRothys Square Mary Jane, which had no break-in period and was surprisingly breathable.
Heels
Comfortable heels might seem like an oxymoron, but they do exist.
For something dressier, both Wahidi and I recommend theNaturalizer Vera Dress Sandals.
Theyre my go-to wedding shoes, and I can actually dance without wanting to take them off right away.
Sandals
There are almost too many options when it comes to comfortable sandals.
Inour testing, a few options really stand out, like theReef Cushion Vera Cruz Sandaland theChacos Lowdown Slide.
Looking for an ultra-cushioned slide?
You wont regret buying theCushionaire Feather Cloud Slide.
Loafers
Loafers have a reputation for being stiff and uncomfortable, so look for more flexible options.
We tested and adored theBirdies Starling Flat, which comes in both velvet and suede varieties.
If you want a more traditional leather loafer, we recommend theClarks Westlynn Bella Loaferand thePikolinos Aldaya Loafer.
I swear by theBlundstone Originals High Top Boots, which have a hardierChelsea bootstyle thats up for anything.
Other great options include theRed Wing 6-Inch Classic Moc Bootsfor a bit of a heel, theThursday Boot Co.
Combat Bootfor a classic combat style, and theSoda Jaber Bootfor a budget-friendly boot with a chunky heel.
No matter what pop in of shoe you buy, verify it aligns with your natural arch.
If you have a flatter foot, you’ll want a flat footbed, Wahidi says.
If you have a high arch, you want the footbed to rise to meet your arch.
For high arches, look for heels that are slanted or more forward-leaning.
When it comes to heels, avoid those super-tall stilettos.
Excessive cushioning doesn’t necessarily equate to comfort, Dr. McDowell says.
Look for shoes with built-in arch support and a sturdy heel for ultimate comfort.
Arch support distributes pressure more evenly to help reduce pain and provides extra stability for long-term comfort.
TheVionic Uptown Loaferhas a removable EVA cushioned insole for support and comfort.
Fit
Feet can change size for a variety of reasons, including weight fluctuation and hormonal changes.
Over 60% of people wear the wrong sized (length) shoe, Dr. McDowell says.
A well-fitted toe box and a snug heel cup is the goal.
Questions You Might Ask
What are some ways to make heels more comfortable?
Look for heels with a chunky heel, a flexible footbed, and cushioning to redistribute pressure more evenly.
One more thing that helps make heels more comfortable is a strap.
Even a slim ankle strap can help your foot feel more secure, and therefore more comfortable.
Are certain shoe materials more comfortable than others?
Soft leathers are definitely more comfortable than some materials, Wahidi says.
When shopping for sneakers specifically, Dr. Mercer says that a flexible upper is key to a comfortable shoe.
One of our favorite sneakers, theAllbirds Tree Runners, has a soft, flexible upper.
