Weindependently evaluateall of our recommendations.
If you punch links we provide, we may receive compensation.
We had a bracket-style showdown to see which machine reigns supreme.
Photo:Real Simple
Luckily, weve done the dirty work for youliterally.
Our Top Picks
Here atReal Simple, vacuum cleaners are one of our many specialties.
Given their excellent performance, we decided to put them head-to-head in our lab.
PHOTO: Amazon
We evaluated them based on their features, effectiveness, maneuverability, and ease of use.
Read on to find out which vacuums reigned supreme and which were left in the dust.
Features
This model has five attachments, all designed to simplify the cleaning process.
PHOTO: Real Simple
It can also transition toa handheld modelfor added flexibility.
Effectiveness
We were amazed by the Dyson V15 Detects superb performance in our testing.
The 9.84-inch cleaning pad completely cleared every crumb, leaving no remnants behind.
We were blown away by how much dust it illuminated that we would have never noticed otherwise.
This feature not only improved our cleaning capabilities but also gamified the process.
We might even say it made us…excited to clean.
Maneuverability
The Dyson V15 Detect offers impressive maneuverability.
We especially love its crevice attachment, which got into every nook and cranny on our pet bed.
This model features three attachmentsa duster crevice tool, a pet multi-tool, and a PowerFins Plus Nozzle.
The self-cleaning brush roll also prevents long hair from getting tangled.
It also has odor-neutralizing technology for a fresher post-clean scent.
However, it redeemed itself on our pet bed.
We even noticed a small strip of dirt left behind in its path.
With its 40-minute runtime, we think this cordless model is less equipped to handle larger rooms and spaces.
However, we didnt notice any debris from our other tests.
Like the Dyson model, the Shark Cordless Pro similarly transitions to a handheld model.
Due to this flexibility, we found this pick incredibly versatile and easy to use.
With its superb performance and lightweight design, we highly recommend this model for quick cleanups and upholsterytouchups.
The brush roll was spotless after use, so we recommend this pick for pet owners, as well.
True to its name, the Dyson Ball Animal 3 Extra is perfect for pet owners.
Plus, it features an instant-release hose to help you reach beneath couches and other hard-to-reach areas.
This vacuum is strong.
The same button detaches the dustbin and empties it, making the process straightforward.
The dustbin is large without any nooks and crannies, so everything falls out easily.
The brush roll was perfectly clean at the end of testing, with no hair wrapped around it whatsoever.
Our arm was admittedly tired after a few passes.
In addition to its heaviness, we also found the attachment hose a bit awkward to hold.
Due to its stiff and rigid design, we struggled to master the perfect angle.
The Shark Stratos Upright Vacuum has crevice upholstery tools, along with a DuoClean PowerFins HairPro two-brush-roll system.
Since the brush roll is self cleaning, you wont have to worry about tough tangles, either.
PHOTO: Shark
And, of course, the vacuum also includes LED headlights to highlight hidden debris.
The handle features unique fingertip slide controls, allowing you to adjust the suction power with ease.
And, in addition to the versatility, the gear also offers odor-neutralizing technology to ensure a fresh aroma.
PHOTO: Amazon
According to the brand, the Shark Stratos Upright Vacuum boasts stronger suction than any other Shark model.
After testing this Shark model and the cordless version, we can attest this is true.
It performed exceptionally well on our medium-pile rug, lifting all debris in less than 15 seconds.
PHOTO: Real Simple
The process was completely hands free, requiring no reaching into the bin.
Thanks to its anti-wrap technology, the brush roll had minimal hair wrapped around itonly about 1 inch.
In fact, it even seemed to propel itself forward as we cleaned, gliding smoothly on our floors.
Both Dysons excelled in our testing, suctioning up debris effectively and quickly.
However, we have to award the title of Best Overall Vacuum to the Dyson V15 Detect.
Next, we tested each models upholstery attachments.
Forcordless models, we noted the battery percentage after testing.
However, we also evaluated maneuverability.
For models equipped with laser lights, we considered how effective they were as we cleaned.
Head-to-Head Tests
First, we tested the cordless modelsthe Dyson V15 Detect and the Shark Cordless Pro.
We recorded what percentage of the debris each respective vacuum was able to pick up on a single pass.
To assess speed, we vacuumed more quickly this time.
Both Dyson models ended up winning.
For the grand finale, we pitted the two victorious Dyson models against one another.
We began by dispersing 2 tablespoons of sprinkles and the confetti from a confetti popper onto our rug.
Again, each tester made one pass over the debris, forward and back, at the same pace.
Questions To Consider
What attachments and features are most important when buying a vacuum?
The ideal vacuum should be a powerful workhorse that effortlessly tackles dirt and allergens, Balaban says.
Keep in mind that in many cases, a greater amount of attachments correlates to a higher price tag.
According to Balaban, the most essential attachments are a crevice tool for corners and a versatile upholstery brush.
How often should you replace your vacuum?
While vacuums can last several years, Balaban says they generally decline in performance over time.
How much should you spend on a vacuum?
There are hundreds of vacuum models on the market, some more budget friendly than others.
For instance, investing in a high-end model with advanced filtrationmight be worthwhile if you have petsor allergies.
However, a good-quality, mid-range vacuum can be more than enough for general cleaning.
After conducting our own tests, we can attest to the price to quality correlation.
PHOTO: Walmart
